SBI Term Loan: RLLR: 8.15 | 7.25% - 8.55%
Canara Bank: RLLR: 8 | 7.15% - 9.85%
ICICI Bank: RLLR: -- | 8.5% - 9.65%
Punjab & Sind Bank: RLLR: 7.3 | 7.35% - 10.75%
Bank of Baroda: RLLR: 7.9 | 7.2% - 8.95%
Federal Bank: RLLR: -- | 7.35% - 9.6%
IndusInd Bank: RLLR: -- | 7.6% - 10%
Bank of Maharashtra: RLLR: 8.05 | 7% - 9.15%
Yes Bank: RLLR: -- | 7.4% - 10.54%
Karur Vysya Bank: RLLR: 8.8 | 8.5% - 10.65%
HDFC Bank: RLLR: -- | 7.75% - 13.2%
Axis Bank: RLLR: -- | 8% - 9.1%
IDBI Bank: RLLR: -- | 7.4% - 10%

Bombay Realty and Bombay Dyeing ordered to refund INR 1.95 crore to Dadar homebuyers with 9% interest

#Law & Policy#Infrastructure#India#Maharashtra#Mumbai City#Dadar (East)
Synopsis

The Maharashtra State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission has directed Bombay Realty and The Bombay Dyeing and Manufacturing Company to jointly and severally refund INR 1.95 crore to two homebuyers who cancelled their booking in the Two ICC project at Dadar East, Mumbai, in 2016 following construction delays and a dispute over the payment schedule. The commission also ordered 9% annual interest from the respective dates of deposit, INR 1 lakh as compensation and INR 50,000 towards litigation costs.

The Maharashtra State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission has directed Bombay Realty and The Bombay Dyeing and Manufacturing Company Ltd to refund INR 1.95 crore to two homebuyers who did not receive possession of an apartment booked in the Two ICC residential project at Island City Centre, Dadar East, Mumbai. The commission ordered the developers to pay 9% annual interest on the deposited amount from the respective dates of payment until realisation, along with INR 1 lakh in compensation and INR 50,000 towards litigation costs.


The complaint was filed by two residents of Jamshedpur, Raj Kumar Agarwal and Rahul Agarwal, who had booked Flat No. 801 in the project in 2014. The apartment, measuring approximately 1,941 sq ft and accompanied by two car parking spaces, was priced at INR 9.94 crore. The buyers initially paid INR 25 lakh on 29 August 2014, followed by an allotment letter issued on 6 October 2014 under a 30:70 payment arrangement. Their total payment towards the apartment, including tax deducted at source, amounted to approximately INR 1.95 crore.

Under the original arrangement, 30% of the consideration was payable during construction, while the remaining 70% was linked to possession. According to the complainants, construction was delayed by more than a year despite their adherence to the initial payment milestones. They subsequently sought a revision of the payment arrangement to a construction-linked schedule, under which instalments would correspond to progress at the project site.

However, the developers allegedly continued raising payment demands under the original arrangement instead of issuing a revised schedule. On 6 September 2016, the buyers received a pre-termination notice warning of cancellation of the allotment and forfeiture of the amount paid. They cancelled the booking in October 2016 and sought a refund with interest.

The developers opposed the complaint, arguing that the buyers had defaulted on their payment obligations and that the contractual terms permitted cancellation and forfeiture. They also challenged the consumer commission's jurisdiction by relying on an arbitration clause in the booking documents and argued that the complaint was barred by limitation, as the booking had been cancelled in 2016.

The commission rejected these objections. It held that the retention of homebuyers' money without delivering possession constituted a continuing wrong and that the buyers could seek a refund with reasonable interest. It also observed that an arbitration clause in the booking documents did not remove the statutory remedies available under consumer protection law. The commission treated the developers' continued retention of the deposited amount, without delivery of the apartment, as a deficiency in service and an unfair trade practice.

The dispute had also involved earlier legal proceedings initiated by the buyers in Jamshedpur. Criminal proceedings were quashed by the Jharkhand High Court in December 2021, and the Supreme Court dismissed the subsequent special leave petition in May 2022 while preserving the buyers' right to pursue civil remedies for recovery. The developers issued another demand letter in January 2022, before the buyers filed their consumer complaint in August 2022.

The commission, comprising Presiding Member Poonam V Maharshi and Member Nisha Chavhan, allowed the complaint and directed the two companies to make the refund jointly and severally. The order reinforces that contractual forfeiture provisions and arbitration clauses cannot automatically prevent homebuyers from seeking statutory consumer remedies when a developer retains their money without delivering the promised property.

Source PTI

Discussion

Have something to say? Post your comment