SBI Term Loan: RLLR: 8.15 | 7.25% - 8.55%
Canara Bank: RLLR: 8 | 7.15% - 9.85%
ICICI Bank: RLLR: -- | 8.5% - 9.65%
Punjab & Sind Bank: RLLR: 7.3 | 7.35% - 10.75%
Bank of Baroda: RLLR: 7.9 | 7.2% - 8.95%
Federal Bank: RLLR: -- | 7.35% - 9.6%
IndusInd Bank: RLLR: -- | 7.6% - 10%
Bank of Maharashtra: RLLR: 8.05 | 7% - 9.15%
Yes Bank: RLLR: -- | 7.4% - 10.54%
Karur Vysya Bank: RLLR: 8.8 | 8.5% - 10.65%
HDFC Bank: RLLR: -- | 7.75% - 13.2%
Axis Bank: RLLR: -- | 8% - 9.1%
IDBI Bank: RLLR: -- | 7.4% - 10%

Bombay High Court quashes further EOW probe order in Mumbai redevelopment case

#Law & Policy#Infrastructure#India#Maharashtra#Mumbai City
Synopsis

The Bombay High Court has set aside a magistrate's order directing further investigation into allegations of fraud involving Nish Developers' redevelopment project at Haji Kasam Chawl and Islam Mill Compound in Mumbai's Currey Road. Justice Shivkumar Dige accepted the Economic Offences Wing's closure report after noting that two investigating agencies had examined the allegations and found no offence made out. The dispute involved claims of manipulated property records and Floor Space Index benefits exceeding INR 2,000 crore. The redevelopment scheme had also been upheld by the High Power Committee and the High Court.

The Bombay High Court has quashed an order directing the Economic Offences Wing (EOW) to conduct further investigation into alleged fraud in the redevelopment of Haji Kasam Chawl and Islam Mill Compound at Currey Road in Mumbai. Justice Shivkumar Dige set aside the magistrate's order and accepted the EOW's B-summary report, which concluded that no offence was made out. 
The ruling, delivered on October 5, followed a revision application filed by Nish Developers Pvt Ltd against an August 28 order passed by the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate at the 47th Esplanade court in Mumbai. The magistrate had directed further investigation after considering a protest petition filed by complainant Vinod Jain. 
Jain had alleged that the developer, with the assistance of authorities, manipulated records and created forged documents to show that structures existed on the property before 1969. According to his allegations, this enabled the developer to obtain a Floor Space Index (FSI) of 4 and benefits worth more than INR 2,000 crore. 
Nish Developers' lawyers, Madhur Surana and Sandeep Singh, argued that the allegations had already been investigated twice. The first investigation was conducted by Kherwadi Police Station, which filed a B-summary report after finding no basis to proceed with the allegations. Following Jain's protest petition, the matter was referred for further investigation to the EOW, which also filed a B-summary report after examining the case. 
The developer's lawyers said the EOW had reviewed assessment records, rent receipts, City Survey records and documents from the Maharashtra Housing and Area Development Authority (MHADA), besides recording statements of concerned officials. They argued that the magistrate had ordered another investigation without identifying what remained unexamined in the previous inquiry. 
The defence also submitted that the redevelopment project involved 642 cess structures and 52 non-cess structures, with more than 95% of occupants having consented to the redevelopment. The project had received approval from the state's High Power Committee, and its validity had previously been upheld by the Bombay High Court. The lawyers further argued that Jain was neither a tenant nor an occupant or member of the property. 
In its order, the High Court observed that the magistrate had directed further investigation without explaining which aspects of the case remained unresolved. Justice Dige noted that the EOW had already conducted an in-depth investigation and that the magistrate had not properly considered its findings before ordering another inquiry. 
The court also noted that Jain had previously challenged the redevelopment scheme before the High Power Committee and the High Court. It observed that the magistrate had not adequately considered these earlier proceedings while deciding to direct further investigation. 
The judge further noted that two independent investigating agencies had examined the allegations, collected documents, recorded witness statements and sought explanations from the concerned authorities before filing their closure reports. The court rejected Jain's contention that he was acting as a whistleblower, observing that the case record did not support that claim. It also found substance in the developer's allegations concerning Jain's conduct. 
The High Court consequently allowed Nish Developers' revision application, quashed the magistrate's August 28 order and accepted the EOW's B-summary report, bringing the demand for further investigation to an end at this stage. 
The ruling addresses the scope of further criminal investigation when two agencies have already examined allegations and submitted closure reports. For redevelopment projects, the case also illustrates how disputes over property records, historical structures and FSI benefits can lead to prolonged legal proceedings even after a redevelopment scheme has received regulatory and judicial approval. The High Court's decision removes the specific direction for another EOW investigation in this case. The order does not, by itself, establish a general bar on further investigations in other redevelopment disputes.

Discussion

Have something to say? Post your comment