SBI Term Loan: RLLR: 8.15 | 7.25% - 8.55%
Canara Bank: RLLR: 8 | 7.15% - 9.85%
ICICI Bank: RLLR: -- | 8.5% - 9.65%
Punjab & Sind Bank: RLLR: 7.3 | 7.35% - 10.75%
Bank of Baroda: RLLR: 7.9 | 7.2% - 8.95%
Federal Bank: RLLR: -- | 7.35% - 9.6%
IndusInd Bank: RLLR: -- | 7.6% - 10%
Bank of Maharashtra: RLLR: 8.05 | 7% - 9.15%
Yes Bank: RLLR: -- | 7.4% - 10.54%
Karur Vysya Bank: RLLR: 8.8 | 8.5% - 10.65%
HDFC Bank: RLLR: -- | 7.75% - 13.2%
Axis Bank: RLLR: -- | 8% - 9.1%
IDBI Bank: RLLR: -- | 7.4% - 10%

Bombay HC orders compensation for Bhayandar land owners, 37 years after MTNL took possession

#Law & Policy#Land#India#Maharashtra#Mumbai City
Synopsis

The Bombay High Court has directed the Special Land Acquisition Officer (SLAO) and Thane Collector to determine and pay compensation to the legal heirs of original landowners for 6,900 sq metres of land in Bhayandar, Thane, taken over by state-run Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Limited (MTNL) in April 1989 without any acquisition ever being completed. A bench of Justices Manish Pitale and Shreeram V. Shirsat held that the decades-long delay violated the petitioners' constitutional right to property under Article 300A, and fixed the 2005 date of filing the writ petition as the reference point for determining the land's market value, with MTNL directed to bear the financial burden of the compensation.

The Bombay High Court has ordered the state government's Special Land Acquisition Officer (SLAO) to determine and pay compensation to the legal heirs of a group of original landowners in Bhayandar, Thane district, for 6,900 sq metres of land that state-run Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Limited (MTNL) has occupied and built upon since April 1989, without any formal acquisition or payment of compensation ever being completed. 
A division bench of Justices Manish Pitale and Shreeram V. Shirsat, in a judgment pronounced on 7 September, allowed the writ petition originally filed by Evelyn Paul Pereira and other landowners in 2005, holding that the decades-long deprivation of the petitioners' land without compensation violated their constitutional right to property under Article 300A. The petitioners, now represented by their legal heirs and later substituted by assignees under a registered deed of transfer, sought either a direction to formally acquire the land and pay compensation, or, alternatively, restoration of vacant possession after demolishing the structures MTNL had built on it. 
The case traced back to 1982, when the state issued a notification to acquire large tracts of the petitioners' land in Bhayandar under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, with a formal declaration following in 1985. Separately, under the now-repealed Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, the land had at various points been declared surplus, excluded from surplus, and then re-included, as the matter bounced between the competent authority, an appellate authority and the High Court over nearly two decades. In 1988, amid a pending civil suit, the petitioners agreed to hand over the disputed 6,900 sq metres to MTNL, on the state's undertaking that acquisition would be withdrawn from their remaining land, and possession was formally transferred on 17 April 1989. MTNL had deposited over INR 9.13 lakh toward compensation for the land in 1987, but this amount was refunded to it in 1999 after the SLAO concluded acquisition was no longer necessary. 
The competent authority under the ULC Act finally confirmed, in an order dated 21 October 2003, that the land stood excluded from surplus land, restoring the petitioners' underlying claim. The petitioners issued a legal notice in April 2004 and filed the present writ petition in May 2005, seeking compensation or return of the land. 
MTNL opposed the petition on grounds of delay and laches, arguing that the petitioners had waited 16 years after handing over possession before approaching the court, and that with buildings constructed and multiple tenants now occupying the premises, restoring possession was impractical. The court agreed that restoring vacant possession was not a viable remedy but rejected the delay argument, holding that the petitioners had pursued their ULC Act remedies diligently and could not have effectively claimed compensation until the 2003 order clarified their entitlement. 
Relying on the Supreme Court's rulings in Kolkata Municipal Corporation v. Bimal Kumar Shah and Bernard Francis Joseph Vaz v. Government of Karnataka, which recognised seven sub-rights flowing from the right to property, including the right to fair compensation and the right to an expeditious process, the bench held that the petitioners had been denied these rights for decades while MTNL continued to earn rental income from structures built on the land. 
The court directed the SLAO to treat the case as one where acquisition had been initiated but no award made, fixing 6 May 2005, the date the writ petition was filed, as the reference date for determining the land's market value under the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013. It ordered the SLAO to complete this determination within six months, with MTNL required to deposit the resulting amount within two weeks of being notified, and the SLAO to disburse it to the petitioners within a further week. The Thane Collector was separately directed to determine rental compensation for the 16-year period between 1989 and 2005 within eight weeks, again payable by MTNL. An earlier INR 5 lakh interim deposit made in the case, along with accrued interest, was ordered released to the petitioners immediately, to be adjusted against the final compensation amount. 
Source- India Kanoon

Discussion

Have something to say? Post your comment