The Gulf conflict has disrupted global supply chains, pushed...
REITs have changed the way commercial real estate is owned a...
What really powers the cloud? Behind every Google search, A...
What really powers the cloud? Behind every Google search, A...
Luxury real estate is one of the most talked-about segments ...
The Bombay High Court has issued two recent orders concerning redevelopment and cooperative housing societies in Mumbai, addressing separate issues around society formation and members delaying redevelopment. In a Prabhadevi case, the court cancelled the registration of a separate society created for two wings of an existing four-wing building, holding that bifurcation procedures must be followed before a new society can be formed. In a separate Kandivali case, the court directed two members to hand over their flats after they failed to execute permanent alternative accommodation agreements, observing that redevelopment cannot be kept pending indefinitely because of individual non-cooperation.
The Bombay High Court has passed two recent orders concerning redevelopment and the functioning of cooperative housing societies in Mumbai, with the cases dealing with separate society formation and delays caused by individual members. The orders relate to housing projects in Prabhadevi and Kandivali and examine how existing society structures and redevelopment agreements should operate when disputes arise between residents, developers and societies.
In the Prabhadevi matter, Justice Sandeep Marne cancelled the registration of a separate housing society created for the A and B wings of a four-wing building where an existing society was already registered. The petitioner, Swa Griha Cooperative Housing Society Ltd, is associated with a MHADA building that was redeveloped through Sugee Developers and comprises 240 flats. The building received its occupancy certificate in March 2024.
Following the redevelopment, the chief promoter of Atharva Cooperative Housing Society applied for registration of a separate society for the sale-component A and B wings. The deputy registrar granted registration in February 2025. After challenges before the joint registrar and the cooperation minister did not succeed, the existing society approached the High Court.
The court set aside the orders of the deputy registrar, joint registrar and cooperation minister, holding that residents seeking a separate society cannot directly obtain registration when an existing society already covers the building. Justice Marne said the appropriate route would involve a two-thirds majority resolution for bifurcation or an application to the registrar, followed by the prescribed procedure.
The court also noted that the four wings shared common infrastructure, including the terrace, underground water tank, water supply lines, electricity meter, vehicle entry and gymnasium. Allowing a new society to be registered without first bifurcating the existing society, the court observed, could result in multiple societies being registered for the same building. The court has stayed its judgment for six weeks following a request from the opposing side.
In a separate Kandivali redevelopment case, Justice Amit Borkar directed two members of Charkop Dhanwantari Kabira Cooperative Housing Society to hand over possession of their vacant flats to the developer. The society comprises two buildings around 35 years old with 36 occupants and had entered into a development agreement with Dev Pooja Builders Pvt Ltd in August 2025.
Under the agreement, members were to receive replacement premises based on their existing units, along with an additional area equivalent to 41% of their existing premises. The arrangement also included one car parking space per member, a maintenance corpus, transit funding, rent, brokerage and shifting charges.
After obtaining the required permissions, the developer asked members to execute their individual permanent alternative accommodation agreements and vacate their premises. While 34 members had completed the process and vacated their flats, two members did not execute their agreements or hand over possession. The developer approached the court, stating that demolition and redevelopment could not proceed while the two flats remained occupied.
The court held that the members could not keep the redevelopment process pending indefinitely by declining to come forward for execution of their individual agreements. It directed the two members to hand over possession, while noting that any disagreement regarding the area of their alternative accommodation could not be used to prevent redevelopment under the existing development agreement.
Together, the two cases highlight different legal issues that can arise during Mumbai's redevelopment process. While the Prabhadevi order dealt with the procedure required to create a separate cooperative society within an existing building structure, the Kandivali order concerned the obligation of individual members to comply with arrangements already agreed for redevelopment. Both cases underline the importance of following the prescribed cooperative society procedures and contractual arrangements as redevelopment projects move towards execution.
Source Bombay High Court
20th Oct, 2026
3rd Oct, 2026
28th Sep, 2026
24th Sep, 2026
4th Aug, 2026