The Gulf conflict has disrupted global supply chains, pushed...
REITs have changed the way commercial real estate is owned a...
What really powers the cloud? Behind every Google search, A...
What really powers the cloud? Behind every Google search, A...
Luxury real estate is one of the most talked-about segments ...
The Calcutta High Court has directed the New Town Kolkata Development Authority (NKDA) to demolish all construction beyond 18,218 square feet in the retail block of the Rosedale Garden housing complex in New Town, Kolkata. A Division Bench of Justices Rajasekhar Mantha and Anuj Singh, ruling on 14 September on an appeal by the Rosedale Garden Apartment Owners Association, held that the complex's residential towers and retail area form a single housing project spanning 16.32 acres, and that the retail block's construction rights were confined to the area legally purchased by its operator. NKDA has been given two months to carry out the demolition and recover its costs from the retail plot's owner.
The Calcutta High Court has directed the New Town Kolkata Development Authority (NKDA) to demolish unauthorised construction at the Rosedale Garden residential complex in New Town, ruling that the project's retail block had exceeded the built-up area it was legally entitled to.
The judgment, delivered by a Division Bench of Justices Rajasekhar Mantha and Anuj Singh, disposed of an appeal filed by the Rosedale Garden Apartment Owners Association against a February 2024 single-bench order. The appeal was heard over several sessions, with arguments concluding on 7 September and the verdict delivered a week later, on 14 September.
The dispute centred on a 16.32-acre plot in Mouza Patharghata, developed under a 2006 agreement between the West Bengal Housing and Infrastructure Development Corporation (HIDCO) and Rosedale Developer Pvt Ltd (RDPL) for a residential complex comprising six towers, a clubhouse and ancillary retail facilities. A retail block within the project, measuring 18,218 square feet, was subsequently sold to an entity operating as Rosedale Plaza (RP). Long-running litigation followed over which sanctioned building plan governed the retail area: the original 2009 plan issued by HIDCO, or a revised plan sanctioned by NKDA in April 2011 that had reduced the retail block's permissible size.
The single bench had earlier held that the 2009 HIDCO plan remained valid and declined to order any demolition. The Division Bench reversed that finding, holding that the NKDA's revised 2011 plan was the only valid sanction plan governing the project, since it had been acted upon and relied on by both the apartment owners' association and RP in subsequent proceedings and transactions, including RP's own 2014 purchase deed.
The court found that Rosedale Garden and its retail block together formed a single residential housing project, and that the retail area existed to serve residents rather than function as an independent commercial development. It noted that RP's ownership rights extended only to 18,218 square feet out of a larger retail area sanctioned under the plans, and that any construction beyond that area, or departing from the NKDA-sanctioned plan, was unauthorised.
The court referred to an NKDA inspection that had earlier identified several deviations at the site, including unauthorised commercial outlets, boundary fencing separating the retail and residential portions, a toilet block and gas installation obstructing an internal road, and unsanctioned additions to the retail building's roof.
In its directions, the court set aside a 2019 NKDA order that had permitted the retail developer to regularise the deviations, and instructed NKDA to ensure all existing construction complies with the original 2006 development agreement and the 2011 revised plan. NKDA has been directed to demolish all construction by the retail block's operator beyond the 18,218 square feet sanctioned to it, and to remove the fencing separating the residential and commercial sections, within two months. The court ordered that the cost of demolition be recovered from the retail block's owner. It permitted the retail operator to cordon off its sanctioned 18,218 square feet with limited access, to preserve residents' privacy, and made no order as to costs.
Source: Calcutta High Court
17th Nov, 2026
16th Nov, 2026
12th Nov, 2026
10th Nov, 2026