The Gulf conflict has disrupted global supply chains, pushed...
REITs have changed the way commercial real estate is owned a...
What really powers the cloud? Behind every Google search, A...
What really powers the cloud? Behind every Google search, A...
Luxury real estate is one of the most talked-about segments ...
The Calcutta High Court has upheld the conviction of a developer and a property owner for raising an unauthorised four-storeyed (G+3) building in a congested Kolkata lane, holding that actual structural collapse or post-facto forensic evidence is not necessary to establish an offence under Section 401A of the Kolkata Municipal Corporation Act, 1980. Justice Uday Kumar dismissed the criminal revision petition filed by developer Biplab Saha and property owner Shukla Das, ruling that once unauthorised multi-storey construction is proved, the likelihood of danger to human life or civic infrastructure is a direct statutory presumption.
The Calcutta High Court has upheld the conviction of a developer and a property owner for constructing an unauthorised four-storeyed building in a congested lane in Kolkata, ruling that structural audits or soil tests are not mandatory to establish the likelihood of danger to human life or public infrastructure under municipal law.
Justice Uday Kumar dismissed the criminal revision petition filed by developer Biplab Saha and property owner Shukla Das, who had challenged their conviction under Section 401A of the Kolkata Municipal Corporation Act, 1980. Their building, at premises No. 26/D, Dr Panchanan Mitra Lane, had been sanctioned only up to Ground plus one floor (G+1), owing to the narrow access passage serving the property, but a Ground plus three-storey (G+3) structure was raised instead, in clear violation of the sanctioned plan.
The court examined the language of Section 401A, which penalises construction that "endangers or is likely to endanger" human life, or is likely to disrupt civic infrastructure or cause a fire hazard. It held that the use of the disjunctive phrase "endangers or is likely to endanger" meant that an actual structural collapse is not a prerequisite for conviction under the provision. The court observed that when an unauthorised multi-storey structure is erected in a congested urban lane against a restricted single-storey limit, the likelihood of a hazard flows as a direct statutory presumption grounded in objective physical reality, rather than requiring proof of an incident having already occurred.
The court further held that once unauthorised multi-storey construction of this nature is established, post-facto structural forensic audits or soil test reports are not mandatory to sustain a conviction, since the offence is made out from the fact of the unauthorised construction itself, given its scale relative to what was permitted.
In its observations, the court characterised unauthorised construction in a congested metropolis such as Kolkata as more than a mere civil infraction, describing it as something capable of directly affecting public safety and civic infrastructure. It noted that when developers and property owners treat municipal sanction limits as mere suggestions rather than binding commands, criminal law must step in to enforce compliance, given the risks such violations pose to residents of densely built neighbourhoods and to the surrounding built environment.
The ruling adds to a broader pattern of judicial scrutiny of unauthorised construction across West Bengal in recent years, following a series of building collapses and enforcement disputes involving unsanctioned floors added to structures across Kolkata and its surrounding municipal areas. Courts in the state, including the Calcutta High Court itself, have periodically directed civic bodies to act against illegal construction, with the Supreme Court also having previously urged the High Court to ensure that unauthorised buildings across the city are dealt with in accordance with law.
By affirming that likelihood of danger can be presumed from the scale of the violation alone, without requiring additional forensic proof, the judgment is expected to strengthen the position of municipal authorities prosecuting similar unauthorised construction cases in West Bengal going forward, potentially easing the evidentiary burden they face in securing convictions under Section 401A.
Source- PTI
17th Nov, 2026
16th Nov, 2026
12th Nov, 2026
10th Nov, 2026