SBI Term Loan: RLLR: 8.15 | 7.25% - 8.55%
Canara Bank: RLLR: 8 | 7.15% - 9.85%
ICICI Bank: RLLR: -- | 8.5% - 9.65%
Punjab & Sind Bank: RLLR: 7.3 | 7.35% - 10.75%
Bank of Baroda: RLLR: 7.9 | 7.2% - 8.95%
Federal Bank: RLLR: -- | 7.35% - 9.6%
IndusInd Bank: RLLR: -- | 7.6% - 10%
Bank of Maharashtra: RLLR: 8.05 | 7% - 9.15%
Yes Bank: RLLR: -- | 7.4% - 10.54%
Karur Vysya Bank: RLLR: 8.8 | 8.5% - 10.65%
HDFC Bank: RLLR: -- | 7.75% - 13.2%
Axis Bank: RLLR: -- | 8% - 9.1%
IDBI Bank: RLLR: -- | 7.4% - 10%

No tax on value of new property under redevelopment agreement, rules ITAT Mumbai

#Taxation & Finance News#Residential#India#Maharashtra#Mumbai City
Synopsis

The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Mumbai, has ruled that a tenant surrendering existing tenancy rights under a redevelopment agreement cannot be taxed on the stamp duty value of the new premises promised to him, merely because the agreement was registered, when construction remains incomplete and possession has not been handed over. Setting aside additions of INR 1.38 crore made under Section 56(2)(x) of the Income-tax Act in the case of assessee Manoj Devshi Chhadva, the Tribunal held that mere execution and registration of a redevelopment agreement creates only a future contractual right, not an actual "receipt" of immovable property, and that the transaction, being in exchange for surrendered tenancy rights, was in any case supported by valid consideration.

The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Mumbai Bench, has ruled that a tenant who surrenders existing tenancy rights under a redevelopment agreement cannot be taxed on the stamp duty value of the new premises promised to him under Section 56(2)(x) of the Income-tax Act, where the redevelopment project remains incomplete and possession of the new premises has not actually been handed over. 
The case concerned Manoj Devshi Chhadva, who had entered into two registered agreements dated 12 December 2017, registered the following day, for premises Nos. C-1 and C-50, carrying stamp duty values of INR 54,79,000 and INR 83,91,000 respectively, for a combined value of INR 1,38,70,000. The Assessing Officer held that the assessee had received these immovable properties without consideration during the relevant previous year, and invoked Section 56(2)(x) to add the entire stamp duty value as "income from other sources." 
The assessee contended that the new premises had not actually been received, since only agreements had been executed and the redevelopment project remained in progress, and that the agreements had been executed in lieu of his tenancy rights in four existing shops, meaning the transaction was supported by valid consideration. The Assessing Officer rejected these explanations, holding that registration of the agreements had conferred absolute rights over the new premises, and the addition was subsequently upheld by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), NFAC, which held that permanent alternate accommodation under a redevelopment agreement constituted "immovable property" and that the assessee had acquired ownership rights over it upon registration, irrespective of physical possession. 
On appeal, a bench comprising Accountant Member Vikram Singh Yadav and Judicial Member Siddhartha Nautiyal examined whether Section 56(2)(x) could be invoked merely because redevelopment agreements had been executed and registered, notwithstanding that the project remained incomplete and the assessee had not received possession. The Tribunal noted that the charging provision under Section 56(2)(x)(b) applies only where a person "receives" immovable property without consideration during the relevant year, meaning actual receipt is an essential fact that must be established before the provision can be invoked. 
The Tribunal found it undisputed that the assessee had surrendered tenancy rights in exchange for permanent alternate accommodation under the redevelopment scheme, and that the project remained incomplete, with the RERA portal confirming construction was still ongoing and no occupation certificate had been obtained. It held that mere execution or registration of a redevelopment agreement creates only a contractual right to obtain a flat in future upon completion of construction, and does not amount to receipt of the immovable property itself, particularly where the assessee has neither acquired possession nor the right to enjoy the property. 
The Tribunal also rejected the characterisation of the transaction as a gratuitous transfer, holding that the permanent alternate accommodation was being allotted in exchange for surrender of valuable tenancy rights, making the arrangement one of reciprocal consideration rather than a transfer without consideration falling within Section 56(2)(x). 
In reaching its conclusion, the Tribunal relied on a series of coordinate bench decisions, including Snehalata Heramb Dhayagude v. Jurisdictional AO (order dated 21 April 2026), which held that a mere right to receive a property in future, contingent on completion of construction, does not equate to "receipt of immovable property" under the provision, and that surrender of tenancy rights takes effect only once possession of the new premises is handed over. The Tribunal also cited Anil Dattaram Pitale v. ITO [2025] and Amar Narendra Joshi v. ITO [2026], both of which had similarly held that receipt of a new flat in lieu of an old one under a redevelopment agreement does not attract Section 56(2)(x), and that such transactions may, at most, attract capital gains provisions instead. 
Holding that the deeming fiction under Section 56(2)(x) must be construed strictly and cannot be extended beyond receipt actually contemplated by the statute, the Tribunal ruled that the Assessing Officer was not justified in invoking the provision, and allowed the assessee's appeal, setting aside the INR 1,38,70,000 addition in its entirety. 
Source- India Kanoon

Discussion

Have something to say? Post your comment