SBI Term Loan: RLLR: 8.15 | 7.25% - 8.55%
Canara Bank: RLLR: 8 | 7.15% - 9.85%
ICICI Bank: RLLR: -- | 8.5% - 9.65%
Punjab & Sind Bank: RLLR: 7.3 | 7.35% - 10.75%
Bank of Baroda: RLLR: 7.9 | 7.2% - 8.95%
Federal Bank: RLLR: -- | 7.35% - 9.6%
IndusInd Bank: RLLR: -- | 7.6% - 10%
Bank of Maharashtra: RLLR: 8.05 | 7% - 9.15%
Yes Bank: RLLR: -- | 7.4% - 10.54%
Karur Vysya Bank: RLLR: 8.8 | 8.5% - 10.65%
HDFC Bank: RLLR: -- | 7.75% - 13.2%
Axis Bank: RLLR: -- | 8% - 9.1%
IDBI Bank: RLLR: -- | 7.4% - 10%

ITAT rules tax officer cannot pin entire stamp-value gap on one co-owner in Mumbai flat purchase

#Law & Policy#Commercial#India#Maharashtra#Mumbai City
Synopsis

The Mumbai Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) has deleted a INR 35.09 lakh addition made under Section 56(2)(x) of the Income-tax Act against a co-owner of two Matunga flats, holding that a genuine property transaction originating from a 2009 allotment and completed through a civil court decree cannot be taxed merely by comparing the historical purchase consideration with the higher stamp duty value prevailing at the later date of registration. The Tribunal held that the Revenue could not adopt mutually inconsistent conclusions in the hands of different co-owners of the same indivisible property transaction, particularly where the tax department had itself accepted, in the assessment of another co-owner involving the same allotment and payments, that Section 56(2)(x) did not apply.

The Mumbai Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) has ruled that an Assessing Officer cannot attribute the entire gap between a property's agreed consideration and its stamp duty value to a single co-owner, holding that a genuine transaction originating from an earlier allotment and completed through a civil court decree cannot be taxed merely because registration occurred years later at a higher prevailing stamp value. 
The bench, comprising Judicial Member Beena Pillai and Accountant Member Jagadish, deleted an addition of INR 35.09 lakh made under Section 56(2)(x) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, against an assessee who, jointly with other purchasers, had acquired Flats Nos. 301 and 302 on the third floor of Jainik Apartment in Matunga, Mumbai, for a total consideration of INR 2,01,51,570. 
The property had originally been allotted by the builder under an allotment letter dated 29 August 2009, with payments made through banking channels. Disputes subsequently arose with the builder, leading to Suit No. 1936 of 2010 before the Bombay City Civil Court. The conveyance was ultimately executed and registered only in financial year 2019-20, pursuant to the decree and proceedings before the executing court. At the time of registration on 11 September 2019, the Stamp Valuation Authority adopted a value of INR 2,71,70,500, resulting in a difference of INR 70,18,930 between the actual consideration and the stamp duty valuation. The Assessing Officer attributed 50 per cent of this difference to the assessee and treated INR 35,09,465 as income under Section 56(2)(x). 
The Assessing Officer held that the assessee had failed to establish payment of consideration on or before the date of the allotment letter through the mode prescribed under the second proviso to Section 56(2)(x)(b), and accordingly adopted the higher registration-date stamp value. The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) accepted that the 2009 allotment letter had fixed the consideration and found one payment of INR 3,58,316 reflected in the bank statement, but held that payments claimed for August and December 2009 were not conclusively discernible from the records placed before it, and upheld the addition on that basis. 
Before the Tribunal, the assessee argued that the 2019 conveyance was merely the culmination of the 2009 allotment and the subsequent civil court decree, representing the same consideration fixed and acted upon by the parties over a decade earlier rather than a fresh bargain struck at 2019 market values. Crucially, the assessee relied on the scrutiny assessment completed in the case of a co-owner of the very same property, in which the Assessing Officer had examined the same allotment letter, five cheques totalling INR 43.30 lakh paid before 2010, and amounts deposited before the City Civil Court, and had expressly concluded that Section 56(2)(x) did not apply. 
The Tribunal found this inconsistency central to the case. It noted that the co-owner's assessment did not involve an unrelated person or unrelated facts, but the same property, the same allotment, the same consideration, the same payments and the same civil court proceedings, with no material shown to indicate that assessment had since been revised or reopened, and no distinguishing factual circumstances identified by the Revenue between the two co-owners. While acknowledging that res judicata does not strictly govern income-tax proceedings, the Tribunal held that "the Revenue cannot, without any cogent distinguishing material, adopt mutually destructive factual conclusions in the hands of co-owners arising from one indivisible transaction." 
The Tribunal further held that the 2019 registration was not the result of a fresh bargain at prevailing market value, but the legal completion of rights that had originated from the 2009 allotment at a consideration already fixed and partly discharged through banking channels, with the balance subsequently deposited with the court. It also considered the Karnataka High Court's ruling in PCIT v. Dr Ranjan Pai, noting that while that case concerned bonus shares rather than immovable property, its underlying principle, that Section 56(2) is an anti-abuse provision not to be mechanically applied to genuine transactions involving no real untaxed benefit, remained interpretively relevant. 
In view of these findings, the Tribunal held that the INR 35,09,465 addition was unsustainable and directed the Assessing Officer to delete it, allowing the assessee's appeal on this ground while treating related grounds on interest under Sections 234A, 234B and 234C as consequential.

Discussion

Have something to say? Post your comment